Jump to content

What is the "holy grail" now?


Astat

Recommended Posts

9 hours ago, LPLStaff said:

Really the only actual "holy grail" item left in the discography that is known and not just a random demo/song title people know, is No Roads Left with Chester, right?

Isn't it a demo too?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 271
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

58 minutes ago, lpliveusername said:

Isn't it a demo too?

 

Yeah. "We tried it with Chester, too," as Mike described it, doesn't sound like it was fully completed and ready for release. I've always thought that meant Chester took a few passes at it until he realized that Mike's vocals on that song just fit better than his did.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 8/19/2024 at 6:49 PM, Justin said:

 

Yeah. "We tried it with Chester, too," as Mike described it, doesn't sound like it was fully completed and ready for release. I've always thought that meant Chester took a few passes at it until he realized that Mike's vocals on that song just fit better than his did.

Yeah,I remember that

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 8/19/2024 at 9:03 AM, LPLStaff said:

Really the only actual "holy grail" item left in the discography that is known and not just a random demo/song title people know, is No Roads Left with Chester, right?

 

How is that one "known" any more or less than "Fire in the City", 2017 Friendly Fire? I'd say all of them sound like built-out songs, and since NRL is just an alternate of a final track, I'd count the alternate choruses of SIB and stuff in the same category 

Something I don't see on that big list: Sorry For Now with the demo verse Mike rapped during the PT tour. I really want to hear the studio version 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
13 hours ago, thigolpbr said:

Smokeout 2003 full proshot video
Detroit 2003 full Proshot video
Chiba City Summer Sonic 06 Full Proshot Video

 

One day the LP has to release one of these full-length proshot shows.

Don't take this as criticism, it's probably just me, but I never got the level hype people here seem to have for unreleased shows. Like, unless the show has something special like a rare song or stuff like that, I wouldn't care much. But it's just me haha 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

34 minutes ago, Somebodyangry said:

Don't take this as criticism, it's probably just me, but I never got the level hype people here seem to have for unreleased shows. Like, unless the show has something special like a rare song or stuff like that, I wouldn't care much. But it's just me haha 

Of these three shows, two of them have something special to watch:

 

Detroit:
Hit The Floor
Easier to Run

 

Summer Sonic 06:
Reading My Eyes

 

I understand your point of view, each fan has their preferences. I love bootlegs, watching the band's old shows, so for me it would be special.
I believe the closest to these would be if the complete Smokeout leaked and if the band plans to release Summer Sonic 06 DVD on a MTM20th.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 minutes ago, thigolpbr said:

Of these three shows, two of them have something special to watch:

 

Detroit:
Hit The Floor
Easier to Run

 

Summer Sonic 06:
Reading My Eyes

 

I understand your point of view, each fan has their preferences. I love bootlegs, watching the band's old shows, so for me it would be special.
I believe the closest to these would be if the complete Smokeout leaked and if the band plans to release Summer Sonic 06 DVD on a MTM20th.

Oh ok I get it. To me I'd rather have demo stuff even of unfinished songs;) matter of preferences ;)

 

13 minutes ago, Rasputin 93 said:

I mean... this is literally a forum called LPLive, that originated from people collecting live show recordings.

LOL ok  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

UPDATE 3

 

LINKIN PARK - HOLY GRAIL

 

 

XERO ERA

  • Deftest (Full)
  • Snippet Unknown Song (From Xero 4-Track Cassette Demo)
  • Dreamer
  • Weight
  • Pointillism
  • Slip (Mark Wakefield Version)
  • Jeff Blue's Vault (If it really exists…)

—————————————————————

HYBRID THEORY EP ERA

  • And One: Studio Version
  • Flower (Early ''She Couldn't'' Unreleased '99 Demo)
  • Ashes
  • Turn To Grey

—————————————————————

HYBRID THEORY ERA

  • Beat 04 (Mike Shinoda)
  • Beat 10 (Mike Shinoda)
  • Beat 23 (Joe Hahn)
  • Harmonic Song
  • PictureBoard (Alternative Studio Sessions)
  • Possible B-Side For HT Sessions

—————————————————————

_REANIMATION_ ERA

  • My December (DJ Crook Remix/Team Sleep Remix)
  • Outtakes

—————————————————————

[ METEORA ERA]

  • Sick (Don’t Stay Demo)
  • Don’t Stay (Alternate Reggae Version)
  • Nocturnal (Nobody’s Listening Demo)
  • Session (Demo)
  • Numb (Demo)
  • A6 (Version With Vocals)
  • Somewhere I Belong (Alternate Takes)
  • Resolution (The Wizard Song Version)
  • Lost (Thoughts That Take Away My Pride Version)
  • Plaster 2 (Singing Verses Version)
  • Soundtrack (With Vocals)
  • Rhinocerous (With Vocals)
  • Meteora: Remixes
  • Another Meteora B-Side (Like LOST)
  • Healing Foot (NRG Sessions)

—————————————————————

COLLISION COURSE ERA

  • Pre-works (Mike's Demo send to Jay-Z)
  • Demos/B-Side

—————————————————————

MINUTES TO MIDNIGHT ERA

  • Grecian
  • Fire In The City
  • No Roads Left (Chester Version)
  • In Between (Chester Version)
  • Chance Of Rain (Finished Version)
  • Not Alone (MTM Version)
  • Bleed It Out: 1 Of The 99 Other Versions
  • 17th song (?)
  • Japan
  • Armada (Send To Rob)
  • Chunky Munky
  • Sterile Poon
  • Canaries
  • Warhol (Canaries_Canneries)
  • Song A To Z
  • Stitches (Given Up Demo)
  • Shadow Of The Day (Demo)
  • Ammosick (Pre-Mall Demo)
  • MTM B-Side

—————————————————————

A THOUSAND SUNS ERA

  • Ammosick (ATS Version)
  • Blackout (Demo)
  • Powerless (ATS Demo)
  • Monday Meeting
  • Fucking Awesome
  • Chicken Basket
  • Left/Right
  • ATS B-Side

—————————————————————

LIVING THINGS ERA

  • Until It Breaks, Demo N.4
  • Skin To Bone (Demo)
  • Castle Of Glass (Folk Version Demo)
  • Warm Spell (Pre-Mall Demo)
  • LT B-Side

—————————————————————

RECHARGED ERA

  • In My Remains (Remix)
  • Castle Of Glass (LP Remix)
  • Burn It Down (MS Remix)

—————————————————————

THE HUNTING PARTY ERA

  • The Glistening
  • Odyssey/A Line In The Sand (Demo)
  • Coffe (Key To The Kingdom) (Demo)
  • Apes (?)
  • Control/Spotify/Lifejacket
  • White Noise (Pre-Mall Demo)
  • THP B-Side

—————————————————————

MALL ERA

  • Dancer (w/Vocals)
  • Soundtrack Outtakes
  • Original Song For The OST (?)

—————————————————————

ONE MORE LIGHT ERA

  • Friendly Fire (Original 2017 Version)
  • My Horizon
  • Out Of Reach
  • Ricochet
  • Tidal Wave
  • The Wyatt Durrette Song
  • Corin Roddick Song (District 108)
  • One More Light (Mike Version)
  • Can We Go Back
  • Can We Go Back II/The Future
  • Sleepwalking
  • Avicii Possibile Song (?)

—————————————————————

FROM ZERO ERA ⌀

  • Demos
  • B-Sides

—————————————————————

OTHER

xx. Chester Final Songs (2017)

xx. Looking For An Answer (Only Live Version Available, Studio Exists)

xx. Post Traumatic B-Sides

xx. Mike Hangin Out With EG white And K.Flay (?)

xx. Early Works After Hollywood Bowl Show And Before Pandemic (’18-’19)

xx. HT20: Reanimation Remixes

xx. Grey Daze: Old Works/New Works (Without Chazy)

xx. Joe, Mike, Phoenix And Emily Sessions

xx. Meetings With Other Artists Before EastWest Studios And From Zero (Pre-’23)

xx. MS Already Over (Demo With LP?)

xx. The Machine Shop Mixtape 2005 Song

xx. Fort Minor B-Sides

xx. New Divide/Megatron Demo

xx. We Made It: Early Version

xx. Possible Kiaara Featuring Song

xx. Possible Mark Hoppus Featuring Song

xx. Micheal Bublé & Mike Shinoda Collaboration (?)

xx. Sting & Mike Shinoda Collaboration (?)

xx. Welcome (Ryu Mix) (Fort Minor)

xx. I Hate The World Wright Now (2015 Chester Idea)

xx. Head Like A Hole (Korn Featuring Chester Bennington)

xx. U2 Remix By Mike

xx. Crazy Full Song And Master (Slash Feat. Chester Bennington)

xx. Dust Brothers Song

xx. The Prodigy: Remix LP

xx. Various LP Remixes Across The Years (By Or For LP)

xx. Aoki X LP: Complete The Trilogy!

xx  Whatever The Fuck (An Early Mike Shinoda Song)

xx. Kings Of Leon: Remix by LINKIN PARK

xx. Joe Hahn’s BMI: He Who Giveth (?)

xx. Dead By Sunrise: Split Personality Demo

xx. Dead By Sunrise: Evil Twin Demo

xx. Stone Temple Pilots: High Rise EP B-Side

xx. MS x Illenium

 

LINKIN PARK - HOLY GRAIL

Edited by Chazy987
Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 minutes ago, Chazy987 said:

UPDATE 3

 

LINKIN PARK - HOLY GRAIL

 

 

XERO ERA

  • Deftest (Full)
  • Snippet Unknown Song (From Xero 4-Track Cassette Demo)
  • Dreamer
  • Weight
  • Pointillism
  • Slip (Mark Wakefield Version)
  • Jeff Blue's Vault (If it really exists…)

—————————————————————

HYBRID THEORY EP ERA

  • And One: Studio Version
  • Flower (Early ''She Couldn't'' Unreleased '99 Demo)
  • Ashes
  • Turn To Grey

—————————————————————

HYBRID THEORY ERA

  • Beat 04 (Mike Shinoda)
  • Beat 10 (Mike Shinoda)
  • Beat 23 (Joe Hahn)
  • Harmonic Song
  • Possible B-Side For HT Sessions

—————————————————————

_REANIMATION_ ERA

  • My December (DJ Crook Remix/Team Sleep Remix)
  • Outtakes

—————————————————————

[ METEORA ERA]

  • Sick (Don’t Stay Demo)
  • Don’t Stay (Alternate Reggae Version)
  • Nocturnal (Nobody’s Listening Demo)
  • Session (Demo)
  • Numb (Demo)
  • A6 (Version With Vocals)
  • Somewhere I Belong (Alternate Takes)
  • Resolution (The Wizard Song Version)
  • Lost (Thoughts That Take Away My Pride Version)
  • Plaster 2 (Singing Verses Version)
  • Soundtrack (With Vocals)
  • Rhinocerous (With Vocals)
  • Meteora: Remixes
  • Another Meteora B-Side (Like LOST)

—————————————————————

COLLISION COURSE ERA

  • Pre-works (Mike's Demo send to Jay-Z)
  • Demos/B-Side

—————————————————————

MINUTES TO MIDNIGHT ERA

  • Grecian
  • Fire In The City
  • No Roads Left (Chester Version)
  • In Between (Chester Version)
  • Chance Of Rain (Finished Version)
  • Not Alone (MTM Version)
  • Bleed It Out: 1 Of The 99 Other Versions
  • 17th song (?)
  • Japan
  • Armada (Send To Rob)
  • Chunky Munky
  • Sterile Poon
  • Canaries
  • Warhol (Canaries_Canneries)
  • Song A To Z
  • Stitches (Given Up Demo)
  • Shadow Of The Day (Demo)
  • Ammosick (Pre-Mall Demo)
  • MTM B-Side

—————————————————————

A THOUSAND SUNS ERA

  • Ammosick (ATS Version)
  • Blackout (Demo)
  • Powerless (ATS Demo)
  • Monday Meeting
  • Fucking Awesome
  • Chicken Basket
  • Left/Right
  • ATS B-Side

—————————————————————

LIVING THINGS ERA

  • Until It Breaks, Demo N.4
  • Skin To Bone (Demo)
  • Castle Of Glass (Folk Version Demo)
  • Warm Spell (Pre-Mall Demo)
  • LT B-Side

—————————————————————

RECHARGED ERA

  • In My Remains (Remix)
  • Castle Of Glass (LP Remix)
  • Burn It Down (MS Remix)

—————————————————————

THE HUNTING PARTY ERA

  • The Glistening
  • Odyssey/A Line In The Sand (Demo)
  • Coffe (Key To The Kingdom) (Demo)
  • Apes (?)
  • Control/Spotify/Lifejacket
  • White Noise (Pre-Mall Demo)
  • THP B-Side

—————————————————————

MALL ERA

  • Dancer (w/Vocals)
  • Soundtrack Outtakes
  • Original Song For The OST (?)

—————————————————————

ONE MORE LIGHT ERA

  • Friendly Fire (Original 2017 Version)
  • My Horizon
  • Out Of Reach
  • Ricochet
  • Tidal Wave
  • The Wyatt Durrette Song
  • Corin Roddick Song (District 108)
  • One More Light (Mike Version)
  • Can We Go Back
  • Can We Go Back II/The Future
  • Sleepwalking
  • Avicii Possibile Song (?)

—————————————————————

FROM ZERO ERA ⌀

  • Demos
  • B-Sides

—————————————————————

OTHER

xx. Chester Final Songs (2017)

xx. Looking For An Answer (Only Live Version Available, Studio Exists)

xx. Post Traumatic B-Sides

xx. Mike Hangin Out with EG white And K.Flay (?)

xx. Early Works After Hollywood Bowl Show And Before Pandemic (’18-’19)

xx. HT20: Reanimation Remixes

xx. Grey Daze: Old Works/New Works (without Chazy)

xx. Meetings With Other Artists Before EastWest Studios and From Zero (Pre-’23)

xx. MS Already Over (Demo with LP?)

xx. The Machine Shop Mixtape 2005 Song

xx. Fort Minor B-Sides

xx. New Divide/Megatron Demo

xx. We Made It: Early Version

xx. Possible Kiaara Featuring Song

xx. Possible Mark Hoppus Featuring Song

xx. Micheal Bublé & Mike Shinoda Collaboration (?)

xx. Sting & Mike Shinoda Collaboration (?)

xx. Welcome (Ryu Mix) (Fort Minor)

xx. I Hate The World Wright Now (2015 Chester Idea)

xx. Head Like A Hole (Korn featuring Chester Bennington)

xx. U2 Remix By Mike

xx. Crazy Full Song (Slash feat. Chester Bennington)

xx. Dust Brothers Song

xx. The Prodigy: Remix LP

xx. Various LP Remixes Across The Years (by or for LP)

xx. Aoki X LP: Complete The Trilogy!

xx  Whatever The Fuck (An Early Mike Shinoda Song)

xx. Kings Of Leon: Remix by LINKIN PARK

xx. Joe Hahn’s BMI: He Who Giveth (?)

xx. Dead By Sunrise: Split Personality Demo

xx. Dead By Sunrise: Evil Twin Demo

xx. Stone Temple Pilots: High Rise EP B-Side

xx. MS x Illenium

 

LINKIN PARK - HOLY GRAIL

 

Mike Shinoda, Phoenix, Joe and Emily sessions

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, JZLP-RoadsUntraveled said:

 

Mike Shinoda, Phoenix, Joe and Emily sessions

It is already understood in the pre-pandemic and pre-study sessions. I didn't just add the names of Dave, Joe, Mike, and Emily.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 9/15/2024 at 1:44 PM, Chazy987 said:

UPDATE 3

 

LINKIN PARK - HOLY GRAIL

 

 

XERO ERA

  • Deftest (Full)
  • Snippet Unknown Song (From Xero 4-Track Cassette Demo)
  • Dreamer
  • Weight
  • Pointillism
  • Slip (Mark Wakefield Version)
  • Jeff Blue's Vault (If it really exists…)

—————————————————————

HYBRID THEORY EP ERA

  • And One: Studio Version
  • Flower (Early ''She Couldn't'' Unreleased '99 Demo)
  • Ashes
  • Turn To Grey

—————————————————————

HYBRID THEORY ERA

  • Beat 04 (Mike Shinoda)
  • Beat 10 (Mike Shinoda)
  • Beat 23 (Joe Hahn)
  • Harmonic Song
  • Possible B-Side For HT Sessions

—————————————————————

_REANIMATION_ ERA

  • My December (DJ Crook Remix/Team Sleep Remix)
  • Outtakes

—————————————————————

[ METEORA ERA]

  • Sick (Don’t Stay Demo)
  • Don’t Stay (Alternate Reggae Version)
  • Nocturnal (Nobody’s Listening Demo)
  • Session (Demo)
  • Numb (Demo)
  • A6 (Version With Vocals)
  • Somewhere I Belong (Alternate Takes)
  • Resolution (The Wizard Song Version)
  • Lost (Thoughts That Take Away My Pride Version)
  • Plaster 2 (Singing Verses Version)
  • Soundtrack (With Vocals)
  • Rhinocerous (With Vocals)
  • Meteora: Remixes
  • Another Meteora B-Side (Like LOST)

—————————————————————

COLLISION COURSE ERA

  • Pre-works (Mike's Demo send to Jay-Z)
  • Demos/B-Side

—————————————————————

MINUTES TO MIDNIGHT ERA

  • Grecian
  • Fire In The City
  • No Roads Left (Chester Version)
  • In Between (Chester Version)
  • Chance Of Rain (Finished Version)
  • Not Alone (MTM Version)
  • Bleed It Out: 1 Of The 99 Other Versions
  • 17th song (?)
  • Japan
  • Armada (Send To Rob)
  • Chunky Munky
  • Sterile Poon
  • Canaries
  • Warhol (Canaries_Canneries)
  • Song A To Z
  • Stitches (Given Up Demo)
  • Shadow Of The Day (Demo)
  • Ammosick (Pre-Mall Demo)
  • MTM B-Side

—————————————————————

A THOUSAND SUNS ERA

  • Ammosick (ATS Version)
  • Blackout (Demo)
  • Powerless (ATS Demo)
  • Monday Meeting
  • Fucking Awesome
  • Chicken Basket
  • Left/Right
  • ATS B-Side

—————————————————————

LIVING THINGS ERA

  • Until It Breaks, Demo N.4
  • Skin To Bone (Demo)
  • Castle Of Glass (Folk Version Demo)
  • Warm Spell (Pre-Mall Demo)
  • LT B-Side

—————————————————————

RECHARGED ERA

  • In My Remains (Remix)
  • Castle Of Glass (LP Remix)
  • Burn It Down (MS Remix)

—————————————————————

THE HUNTING PARTY ERA

  • The Glistening
  • Odyssey/A Line In The Sand (Demo)
  • Coffe (Key To The Kingdom) (Demo)
  • Apes (?)
  • Control/Spotify/Lifejacket
  • White Noise (Pre-Mall Demo)
  • THP B-Side

—————————————————————

MALL ERA

  • Dancer (w/Vocals)
  • Soundtrack Outtakes
  • Original Song For The OST (?)

—————————————————————

ONE MORE LIGHT ERA

  • Friendly Fire (Original 2017 Version)
  • My Horizon
  • Out Of Reach
  • Ricochet
  • Tidal Wave
  • The Wyatt Durrette Song
  • Corin Roddick Song (District 108)
  • One More Light (Mike Version)
  • Can We Go Back
  • Can We Go Back II/The Future
  • Sleepwalking
  • Avicii Possibile Song (?)

—————————————————————

FROM ZERO ERA ⌀

  • Demos
  • B-Sides

—————————————————————

OTHER

xx. Chester Final Songs (2017)

xx. Looking For An Answer (Only Live Version Available, Studio Exists)

xx. Post Traumatic B-Sides

xx. Mike Hangin Out with EG white And K.Flay (?)

xx. Early Works After Hollywood Bowl Show And Before Pandemic (’18-’19)

xx. HT20: Reanimation Remixes

xx. Grey Daze: Old Works/New Works (without Chazy)

xx. Meetings With Other Artists Before EastWest Studios and From Zero (Pre-’23)

xx. MS Already Over (Demo with LP?)

xx. The Machine Shop Mixtape 2005 Song

xx. Fort Minor B-Sides

xx. New Divide/Megatron Demo

xx. We Made It: Early Version

xx. Possible Kiaara Featuring Song

xx. Possible Mark Hoppus Featuring Song

xx. Micheal Bublé & Mike Shinoda Collaboration (?)

xx. Sting & Mike Shinoda Collaboration (?)

xx. Welcome (Ryu Mix) (Fort Minor)

xx. I Hate The World Wright Now (2015 Chester Idea)

xx. Head Like A Hole (Korn featuring Chester Bennington)

xx. U2 Remix By Mike

xx. Crazy Full Song (Slash feat. Chester Bennington)

xx. Dust Brothers Song

xx. The Prodigy: Remix LP

xx. Various LP Remixes Across The Years (by or for LP)

xx. Aoki X LP: Complete The Trilogy!

xx  Whatever The Fuck (An Early Mike Shinoda Song)

xx. Kings Of Leon: Remix by LINKIN PARK

xx. Joe Hahn’s BMI: He Who Giveth (?)

xx. Dead By Sunrise: Split Personality Demo

xx. Dead By Sunrise: Evil Twin Demo

xx. Stone Temple Pilots: High Rise EP B-Side

xx. MS x Illenium

 

LINKIN PARK - HOLY GRAIL

could we add "Healing Foot" from NRG sessions there? even that they more likely just have recorded drums to it, (the blank space song as we can see in the studio song board)

ALSO, Pictureboard seems to have a 2000 studio version too.
(IDK what happened to that thing Jeff Blue was planning, i was looking foward to that)

Edited by unksoldier2000
forgot some info
Link to comment
Share on other sites

18 hours ago, unksoldier2000 said:

could we add "Healing Foot" from NRG sessions there? even that they more likely just have recorded drums to it, (the blank space song as we can see in the studio song board)

ALSO, Pictureboard seems to have a 2000 studio version too.
(IDK what happened to that thing Jeff Blue was planning, i was looking foward to that)

Yeah, thanks man. After they gave us Healing Foot on M20 I already felt full. Damn, I forgot about that making of snippet… god, those drums sound! I'll add both this and PB, I forgot.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 weeks later...

I'd give a lot of money to be able to get that 9-track Xero demo CD with Carousel, Slip, Pointillism, etc.

 

I may be in a minority, but I think the studio recordings of Xero (Rhinestone, Esaul, Pictureboard, Fiends) sound pretty dope for what they were.  I would love to have more of that. A bit sad to know the ods are like 0.001% lol

Edited by Qwerty18
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...