bloodbath

That seems a little bit more realistic

Maybe because many people still considering that LP is Chester Bennington? Wanna talk about numbers? Compare views from instrumental versions with songs with voices. The hardcore fandom is big, but not as much as you think, which doesn't always translate into selling.

Because most people doesn't want it and won't buy it. Plain and simple.

Didn't knew those versions! Which version did they belong?

The more I see this craziness with vinyl varians, the more appreciate my CDs...

90% of LPU members are here hahahahahahahahaah

Are you? For real?

Very useful, thank you!!

Question: Is there any way to tell apart the CD versions that contains LOATR single version and album version? Something like a barcode. I'd like to have the former since it's 10/11 seconds shorter

I can see an ATS20 boxset, not so sure about a Living Thing 20, if you know where I'm going...

I think it comes to a question of cost/benefit. Dealing with Roc Nation or whatever enterprise that has Jay Z's catalog for just an EP with barely any additional stuff, with the risk of being a commercial failure, isn't worth. LP hardcore fan base isn't so big as some people of this forum think. Yeah, Numb/Encore is quite popular, but nobody remember the remaining tracks. Besides, best case scenario, what can you throw on an hypothetical edition? The Roxy, Live 8 show and the MFR 05? That shit fits on one single DVD and it's just for us.

I was hoping to had the remaining Roxy show and the LPU5 tracks on CD, since are impossible to get nowadays. But after two massive boxsets, I can't complain. It would have been a cool bonus anyway!

There's still some hope for half of the Roxy show...

Well... https://www.instagram.com/p/C6_RikzLIeo/?hl=es I hate to be right.

How many songs we have that the band consider as just demos but from the outside are full fledged songs? MTM20 it's going to have a good chunk of those...

I like to call it "play the poor victim to gain sympathy and popularity on the internet". It's obviously a lie, but those people like to be the center of attention for all the wrong reasons

You did a magnificent job back then. Congratulations

I think the 2012 version it's on the physical release too.

Nah, Imagine spending 200 bucks on a boxset, and then having songs cut, DVDs swapped... This is just a regular 10 bucks CD that half of us will buy when it's on offer

Great job @martinez! The physical edition does still have its own problems I assume, like the incorrect version of WFTE

Kurt Cobain is the new vocalist

Until they had decided that the 3CD set has sold enough.

I was highly skeptical about all of this. It's been many years of rumors and speculations that led to nothing. But the thing is, the band has been relatively active since Meteora20. What I mean is we've heard more things about them since, the Papercuts project, while useless on its own, seems to be revealed itself as a way of keeping the flame alive. Hell, look at this forum, it was almost dead through late 2020, to late 2022! For the first time I really believe that something might happen, I'm quite positive. And regarding to the female vocalist matter. As I always say, worst case scenario, you better fuck up doing something different rather than doing the same shit all over again.

The story doesn't say anything at all.

And that's why you don't release this stuff on vinyl