Where does the legend about "the whole band but Mike dislike THP" come from?
Pretty sure Phoenix was quoted about wanting to open shows with KTTK. Chester was always excited about whatever Mike/LP would come up with lol "ATS weird? F*ck yeah!! Heavy metal? F*ck yeah!! Pop? F*ck yeah!!"
Rob gave himself a hard time to be able to play the tracks (the whole back injured with GATS thing), but if anything, that's the record where he shines the most, and probably the challenge must have been interesting to him.
So that leaves Joe and Brad. Brad was famously not really into the guitar stuff at first, and he's the one blamed for the absence of THP on Papercut, soooo he maybe possibly is mid about the record. Joe, we just don't know anything... but he is a huge Rakim fan, so there is that.
Yes, the band did not play all of THP live, but in the end, they've played even less from LT. And yes, we know Mike was the one to initiate the THP direction, but Mike has always been the driving force behind every single LP direction. Like for real, if he wanted to have a Reaggaton LP record, I'm sure he'd find his way to convince the other guys ^^'
I don't know. I feel in general, there is too much speculation about the band disliking certain records, and often, it's not backed up by strong evidence. Meteora haters will say that the band is embarrassed by Meteora, LT haters will say the band only made LT because of the label pressure for more hits, etc. Of course, the band is going to have favorite records, but I highly doubt there is like one record no one is into.