LPLStaff Posted September 29 Author Posted September 29 What if there is a full on explosive track like QWERTY they have never released? The band is always like "LP fans act like there is some gem just sitting on the shelf that is unreleased"... WELL that has turned out to be true for a handful of their albums, especially MTM and Meteora. There is no telling what else exists... they recorded a billion songs in the MTM, ATS, LT, THP, and OML eras. Friendly Fire is not bad either. Quote
Capacity Posted September 29 Posted September 29 some of your theories about why MTM20 won't be released defy all common sense, LOL Quote
mrfox Posted September 29 Posted September 29 1 hour ago, silverwing said: I also don't think tracks like Chances of Rain, Pretend to Be or Across The Line have any chance of blowing huge, far from that. Across the Line, NRL (Chester's vocals) or polished Asbestos would be great singles Quote
Soeffingnaive92 Posted September 29 Posted September 29 2 hours ago, mrfox said: Across the Line, NRL (Chester's vocals) or polished Asbestos would be great singles Imagine if Asbestos had a heavy Chester chorus, it’d be like Victimized meets Given up. Quote
silverwing Posted September 29 Posted September 29 Pale (2006) was just randomly recommended by Youtube to me and some song just like that could be the one secret thing on the vault that might blow. It's the perfect mix between Meteora and MTM. Quote
RYG4R Posted September 29 Posted September 29 NEW STUDIO ALBUM would be awesome if they decided to lean heavily on the ROCK BALLAD side of LINKIN PARK with few exploration of Emily's vocal range (esp Dead Sara's vocal approach). However, I trust them to deliver something new and authentic. Quote
Cesar656 Posted September 30 Posted September 30 Honestly another FZ would be great, they hit a home-run with that and they can do a combo like HT-Meteora and then change Quote
MMM Posted September 30 Posted September 30 (edited) I would like LP9 to be a little heavier than FZ. No ballads in the style of OEO, and for the songs to be longer and have more interesting instrumentals. The line-up is no longer the first youth, and I would prefer them to use their energy and save the lighter style for their later career. Edited September 30 by MMM Quote
bloodbath Posted September 30 Posted September 30 18 hours ago, Soeffingnaive92 said: But imagine what NRL sung by Chester could be. Like, LOATR-ish rock ballad with CB on vocals 10 years after his passing 18 hours ago, silverwing said: I also don't think tracks like Chances of Rain, Pretend to Be or Across The Line have any chance of blowing huge, far from that. Only if they really have something special hiding there, something heavy-ish like Qwerty or more industrial/electronic like New Divide. It comes to my mind "She Couldn't" it's a ballad, an unreleased track from the beloved Hybrid Theory and nobody outside the hardcore fans really cared about. Songs like you've mentioned would be the same case. It would have to be a track very similar to What I've Done, like Lost and Numb. So I'm with @silverwingon this one. We, we would be happy with anything. Imagine that the MTM Boxset ends up being a CD/DVD with a couple of bonus tracks and the Rock Am Ring show. For us means months of endless discussions, but we're a minority. We have to think about what the general audience wants, not us. Quote
ScottiePippo Posted September 30 Posted September 30 41 minutes ago, bloodbath said: It comes to my mind "She Couldn't" it's a ballad, an unreleased track from the beloved Hybrid Theory and nobody outside the hardcore fans really cared about. Songs like you've mentioned would be the same case. It would have to be a track very similar to What I've Done, like Lost and Numb. So I'm with @silverwingon this one. We, we would be happy with anything. Imagine that the MTM Boxset ends up being a CD/DVD with a couple of bonus tracks and the Rock Am Ring show. For us means months of endless discussions, but we're a minority. We have to think about what the general audience wants, not us. She couldn't is a 5 minutes trip-hop instrumental-driven song. It couldn't have been more different from the typical Hybrid Theory sound. On top of that It was already known for years by the majority of hardcore LP fans so we didn't get as excited as for others unreleased songs. They also didn't make a shorter radio edit or a music video. So It was probably meant for Linkin Park fans only, they didn't give that Song a chance to blow up more. In the last couple of years Minutes To Midnight has been performing really strong and currently 3 songs from MTM are in the top 10 of most popular LP songs (just like HT and Meteora). Yeah obviously a hidden song in the style of WID with Chester's vocals would be huge. But even a hard rock/metal song like Given Up or No More Sorrow or a alternative rock ballad like Leave Out All The Rest or Shadow Of The Day would work. The key to success is obviously being previously unreleased and featuring Chester. Even Friend Fire (that being in the style of OML was not exactly in huge demand from fans compared to others eras) proved to be successful enough. Quote
bloodbath Posted September 30 Posted September 30 2 hours ago, ScottiePippo said: She couldn't is a 5 minutes trip-hop instrumental-driven song. It couldn't have been more different from the typical Hybrid Theory sound. On top of that It was already known for years by the majority of hardcore LP fans so we didn't get as excited as for others unreleased songs. They also didn't make a shorter radio edit or a music video. So It was probably meant for Linkin Park fans only, they didn't give that Song a chance to blow up more. In the last couple of years Minutes To Midnight has been performing really strong and currently 3 songs from MTM are in the top 10 of most popular LP songs (just like HT and Meteora). Yeah obviously a hidden song in the style of WID with Chester's vocals would be huge. But even a hard rock/metal song like Given Up or No More Sorrow or a alternative rock ballad like Leave Out All The Rest or Shadow Of The Day would work. The key to success is obviously being previously unreleased and featuring Chester. Even Friend Fire (that being in the style of OML was not exactly in huge demand from fans compared to others eras) proved to be successful enough. You might be right, I won't deny every possible success, what I think is that it is very unlikely that any other B-Side blows up like Lost did. Friendly Fire might be the best example, not huge, not ignored. Quote
aaaaaaA Posted September 30 Posted September 30 I can think of three things they'll do an MTM20 Anniversary, but I have my reservations this will happen, also. 1. They saw that these Anniversary done really well commercially. 2. When I asked Lorenzo at Rock Am Ring this year about the full 2007 RAR performance he told me that it needs to make sense as HT20 RAR 2001 DVD made. 3. Given Up and Shadow of the Day still don't have the HD remastered versions on YouTube. #my2cents Quote
ScottiePippo Posted September 30 Posted September 30 1 hour ago, bloodbath said: You might be right, I won't deny every possible success, what I think is that it is very unlikely that any other B-Side blows up like Lost did. Friendly Fire might be the best example, not huge, not ignored. Yeah that would be very unlikely. But tbh it's not necessary for the whole project to work financially. Lost is one of the most popular archival and posthumous singles of all time. Nothing from HT20 reallly blew up but the whole project was a very big success. MTM is not as huge as HT and Meteora but it's still very big. If they can put together a compilation of previously unreleased material like forgotten demos and lost demos I'm sure it will make sense commercially. They just have to want to do that. This is one of the times when I want Warner to pressure LP into grabbing my cash Quote
LPLStaff Posted September 30 Author Posted September 30 36 minutes ago, ScottiePippo said: If they can put together a compilation of previously unreleased material like forgotten demos and lost demos I'm sure it will make sense commercially. They just have to want to do that. This is one of the times when I want Warner to pressure LP into grabbing my cash Even something like this in the style of Lost Demos should blow up with the fans. Who wouldn't buy this? Rediscovered Demos No Roads Left Across the Line What We Don't Know Blackbirds Not Alone Chance of Rain Pretend to Be *No Roads Left (w/ Chester) *Unreleased song/demo (Ammosick?) *Unreleased song/demo (Dancer?) *Unreleased song/demo - something totally unknown *Unreleased song/demo - something totally unknown *Unreleased song/demo - something totally unknown *Unreleased song/demo - something totally unknown Million possibilities there. Dancer from Mall was an MTM song. The Last Line (Ammosick). They are likely sitting on a million cool things from MTM we don't even know about that could work here. Quote
mrfox Posted September 30 Posted September 30 2 hours ago, bloodbath said: Friendly Fire might be the best example, not huge, not ignored. It is from OML session, sir, there is no successful single. I bet they have some cool song hidden on a hard drive somewhere that’ll pop up out, just like "Lost." Quote
bloodbath Posted September 30 Posted September 30 (edited) 2 hours ago, ScottiePippo said: MTM is not as huge as HT and Meteora but it's still very big. In MTM you still have big mainstream singles: Given Up, WID, BIO, LOATR, but if we enter ATS territory, how many huge songs do we have? WFTE perhaps? For me the remaining albums, for mainstream fans can be categorized as "wow, I didn't hear that song and it's pretty good!". I mean, I heard that tons of people were discovering The Catalyst now, 16 years later, during this tour, which is great, don't get me wrong! But with the exception of Burn it Down, the albums from 2010 to 2017, are more hardcore fan focused. Those boxsets are going to be risky business. Edited September 30 by bloodbath Quote
ScottiePippo Posted September 30 Posted September 30 (edited) 5 hours ago, LPLStaff said: Even something like this in the style of Lost Demos should blow up with the fans. Who wouldn't buy this? Rediscovered Demos No Roads Left Across the Line What We Don't Know Blackbirds Not Alone Chance of Rain Pretend to Be *No Roads Left (w/ Chester) *Unreleased song/demo (Ammosick?) *Unreleased song/demo (Dancer?) *Unreleased song/demo - something totally unknown *Unreleased song/demo - something totally unknown *Unreleased song/demo - something totally unknown *Unreleased song/demo - something totally unknown Million possibilities there. Dancer from Mall was an MTM song. The Last Line (Ammosick). They are likely sitting on a million cool things from MTM we don't even know about that could work here. 100%. A Sea of possibilities regarding MTM. Early stuff that sounded too much like Meteora, tons of demos of existing songs, a lot of demos with scat vocals and nananas, really cool LPU songs only known to the hardcore fanbase and possibly some more songs that got close to the finish line and didn't make it. Even the thought of the existence of another holy grail (maybe grecian, maybe Fire in the city, maybe a mysterious 17th song) makes me wanna open my wallet. I'd be down for any of this possibilities Edited September 30 by ScottiePippo Quote
DXIC Posted September 30 Posted September 30 I agree with many people in this thread that the release of MTM20 is unlikely. In 2007, I had the feeling that everything had already been added to it, and apart from live performances, there was nothing left to add. Quote
ScottiePippo Posted September 30 Posted September 30 4 hours ago, bloodbath said: In MTM you still have big mainstream singles: Given Up, WID, BIO, LOATR, but if we enter ATS territory, how many huge songs do we have? WFTE perhaps? For me the remaining albums, for mainstream fans can be categorized as "wow, I didn't hear that song and it's pretty good!". I mean, I heard that tons of people were discovering The Catalyst now, 16 years later, during this tour, which is great, don't get me wrong! But with the exception of Burn it Down, the albums from 2010 to 2017, are more hardcore fan focused. Those boxsets are going to be risky business. Boxsets are by definition made for hardcore fans because they are expensive as hell to buy. So I would not worry about it being risky business. LP will always have plenty of fans to buy stuff like that if they decide to release them. It all depends on how exciting is what you include, how you want to present it, how big you want to go, etc..HT20 and Meteora20 represent a golden stardard for those type of anniversary release. I've seen a lot of other bands put out similar anniversary releases and they are not as hot as what LP and Warner did. LP could also decide to do future anniversaries on a smaller scale, there would be nothing wrong with that, especially because those albums were infact "smaller" than HT and Meteora. Quote
thigolpbr Posted September 30 Posted September 30 (edited) We can't say for sure, but if the MTM20 box set is being released, it’s likely already in production. The argument about "looking to the future" doesn't make sense; if that were true, the band wouldn't even be playing songs from the HT to OMLeras, so that logic doesn't hold water. The same goes for the idea that releasing material featuring Chester would somehow hurt the current band's performance or plans—that doesn't add up either. They have a new target audience, sure, but they also have an old-school fanbase. Both the label and the band know the MTM20 release would be a huge success; fans love buying that kind of material. Someone needs to ask one of them about it in the coming months. An MTM20 release would be perfect for the gap between studio sessions and the new album—which will likely drop in the second half of the year—so a May 27th release fits perfectly. Let's wait and see what the coming months bring, hoping for some positive news regarding the MTM20 box set. Edited September 30 by thigolpbr Quote
mrfox Posted September 30 Posted September 30 They sold out a book with ugly concert posters in just a few hours at a price of over $200. And you really think they’re going to ignore the MTM 20th anniversary? Unlikely. Quote
AquaTransmission Posted October 29 Posted October 29 (edited) I think they will. Edited October 29 by AquaTransmission Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.