Ok, maybe I'm not very objective here, b'cuz I do like them. But! I have been to the Tilburg show and it surprised me how good they are live, even with Ryan not being 100%.
I can imagine some people won't like it, but I REALLY disliked Coheed & Chlamydia as supportact in '09. So there will always be likers and dislikers.
(and yeah, I'm a liker)