GlassCastles

Basically my rationale

They're playing One More Light tho twice

Dude, I checked the LPL set before you even added the Papercut part, and it was there. And before you say otherwise, I can see the edit log, and the last edit was 20 minutes before the original post, let alone the edited part.

Halfway Right should have been number 2. Anyone who voted for it first got no taste

1. Please try and pay attention. The One More Light intro is just that. An intro. It's an a cappella rendition as was mentioned above. It is the same idea as Breaking The Habit's a cappella outro. If you want to complain about a band playing a song twice, go yell at Paramore. 2. They didn't cut SIB for a new song? It was replaced by POA. Last I checked, POA came out in 2000. I wouldn't call that new, but that's just me. 3. I agree, but that isn't a new development, and most people should have been able to predict that they'd do that, seeing as NEARLY EVERY LEAD SINGLE THE BAND HAS EVER DONE HAS BEEN IN THE ENCORE AT SOME POINT 4. Why are you complaining about the North American tour right now? We're 3 shows into a 18 show European tour. There are two sets, with SIB being in one. Even IF LP kept the same sets from the Europe tour for North America, they probably won't, SIB would still be in there. 5. You're right, 7-8 songs from OML is a joke. There should be 10. HOLY SHIT THEY ARE! WHAT THE FUCK? IT'S IN THE PICTURE THAT YOU POSTED

The election is over! Nobody Can Save Me - 13 One More Light - 6 And by a landslide, Nobody Can Save Me is gone, leaving ONE MORE LIGHT as our victor! FINAL RANKING 1. One More Light 2. Nobody Can Save Me 3. Talking To Myself 4. Sorry For Now 5. Invisible 6. Sharp Edges 7. Battle Symphony 8. Heavy (feat. Kiiara) 9. Good Goodbye (feat. Pusha T & Stormzy) 10. Halfway Right

Dude, you WERE acting like that. It's not even really up for debate. If that wasn't your intention, fine. Just chill out a bit in the future, yeah? When you submit a correction, we will get to it. It may take an hour, it may take a few days, it may take a week or two, but we WILL get to it. Like Dylan said above, this isn't our entire lives, and we more than likely have something important to do if we're not here working to make the database that WE HELPED MAKE FROM THE GROUND UP. We're not going to drop everything just to ensure that a few lines on the Sorry For Now page get fixed because you treat it like it'll be the end of god damned world if anyone reads a line that has two words slightly off. And you posting it 15 times in the same thread isn't going to get us to look into it any faster. It's just going to piss us off. Have a nice day

Round 8 is over! Nobody Can Save Me - 8 Talking To Myself - 15 One More Light - 1 And there goes Talking To Myself 1. Nobody Can Save Me 5. Invisible 9. One More Light Nobody Can Save Me Elimination Tracker 1-2. TBD 3. Talking To Myself 4. Sorry For Now 5. Invisible 6. Sharp Edges 7. Battle Symphony 8. Heavy (feat. Kiiara) 9. Good Goodbye (feat. Pusha T & Stormzy) 10. Halfway Right

Hopeful Europe Set B 1. Fallout (w/ 'Roads Untraveled') 2. The Catalyst 3. One Step Closer (2017 Intro) 4. Papercut 5. Good Goodbye (Ext. Intro; Live Version) 6. Lost In The Echo 7. Nobody Can Save Me 8. Castle Of Glass (Experience Version; 2017 Ending w/ 'A Place For My Head' v1) 9. Battle Symphony 10. New Divide 11. Invisible (Ext. Intro) 12. Numb ('Numb/Encore' Intro/Outro) 13. Waiting For The End ('Remember The Name' Intro; Wall of Noise Outro) 14. Sharp Edges 15. Final Masquerade 16. Burn It Down (Stripped Down) 17. One More Light 18. Heavy 19. From The Inside 20. What I've Done (2017 Intro; Ext. Guitar Solo Bridge) 21. Bleed it Out (Ext. Intro; Ext. Bridge w/ 'Strangelove'; Ext. Ending) ---------------- 22. Leave Out All The Rest (2017 Version) 23. Talking To Myself 24. In The End (Intro Pause) 25. Faint (Ext. Outro)

And I 100% percent agree with that. The mid-set drag in 2014-2015 was worse. MUCH worse. It's a point I've been hammering home for about 5 posts now lol. I genuinely don't see how a 3 song low point is worse than the entire middle section of a set barring one song.

I saw Carnivores, I know how I felt walking in and out of that show. Parts of the intro were solid. GATS, OSC, Rebellion, COG Experience. They went off and were awesome. Blackout interlude sucked the life out of the place, Papercut shortened left people disappointed, someone near me actually left after the Runaway interlude because they were pissed. Every show will be different and get a different reaction. Catalyst is a fucking epic song with a HUGE bridge, WFTE is lit especially with the RTN intro, and One More Light is emotional as hell, especially with a crowd of people singing along, lights in the air etc.. THAT should never leave the set IMO. I'm not disagreeing that ND, BS, Crawling (piano) are poor choices (both at a festival or otherwise), and you're completely free to dislike the set, but trying to say it's such a step down when, if anything, they're about equal as far as "slow stuff/mid-tempo ballads" go (still disagree with that, but let's compromise here) is asinine.

Except I specifically quoted the Carnivores set in the post you replied to, which you proceeded to list a different set from a different tour. And it really is not similarly slow, seeing as, after the initial run, you get BS/ND (fair enough that's slow), but then you get Invisible, RTN/WFTE. BTH, OML, Crawling make up the traditional slow section, then you jump right into LOATR, SIB (don't like it, but it's energetic as hell), WID, toss in ITE with more crowd participation to get them hype, ending with Faint. THP sets had 2 or 3 songs with proper energy mixed in with the boring nonsense in the latter half. Them just running through the set with no breaks for audience involvement/interaction certainly didn't help. The encore is a whole other story and I'm not too thrilled with it, but I still prefer it to Carnivores encore. I explicitly stated the set needs to change soon or it's gonna get old fast and that some variety in song selection is a welcome addition. I'd LOVE to see NMS, BITS, WTCFM, WAK, IMR, Victimized, Rebellion etc. come back. Even with the all-singles set, though, they made it somewhat interesting by at least changing up the order. Like I said earlier, the set isn't perfect, but people are treating it like it's a personal offense to them.

Which Carnivores date did you go to that had that start? Because the dates I know had Mashup Intro>GATS>GU>POA/WY>OSC>Blackout (interlude)>Papercut (short)>Rebellion>Runaway (short)>Wastelands. And this "slow" set has significantly more energy than the 2014 or 2015 sets where they played rock festivals too, or did you forget about that sweet, sweet run of Ballad Medley, Robot Boy (interlude), Joe Solo Medley, BID? Or how about that even better Ballad Medley, Robot Boy (interlude), Joe Solo, ND, BTH, Fallout/DTB, BID? Just the fact that the set isn't broken up by instrumentals and interludes every 5 songs is enough to improve the flow. Oh, and I'd somewhat agree TTM isn't the ideal opener for a rock festival like this, but it is certainly plenty energetic.

Sure, there are some good songs in there, but Given Up takes such a toll on Chester's voice, the Blackout interlude was highly unnecessary, Runaway was literally a verse and chorus. Then you get to the rest of the set. Ballad Medley was so boring, then you had the Robot Boy instrumental and Joe's solo back-to-back which was a dreadful decision, then you get to that encore, which was essentially a huge medley followed by WID and BIO. That super short LITE was such a waste of one of the best live songs this band has, New Divide is not an encore song, Crawling served no purpose there AND sounded bad, and shortening UIG, the most successful single from their latest album, was a terrible choice. BIO with the drum solo and Catalyst sing-a-long didn't have enough to make it a proper closer, either. This set isn't perfect, and some of my complaints then are still valid now (though it's pretty much just the encore and the inclusion of SIB), but it's a hell of an improvement

Not even close. Putting Catalyst in as a "super meh live" song discredits anything else you wrote But seriously, in no way is this worse than some of the ATS sets or THP Carnivores sets. They FINALLY changed up the usual order of songs (bring Catalyst, BID, Castle way up to the front, LOATR at the end etc.), and the first part of the set DOES have a ton of energy, it's just not the usual run of "SUPER DISTORTED GUITAR" songs to kick things off. Oh god no. Crawling studio live is horrific, and has been for a decade Wow. Just, wow. I don't really know where to start with this comment.

Round 7 is over! Nobody Can Save Me - 4 Talking To Myself - 7 Sorry For Now - 11 One More Light - 1 Sorry (For Now) Mike, all your songs are gone. 1. Nobody Can Save Me 3. Talking To Myself 5. Invisible 9. One More Light Talking To Myself Elimination Tracker 1-3. TBD 4. Sorry For Now 5. Invisible 6. Sharp Edges 7. Battle Symphony 8. Heavy (feat. Kiiara) 9. Good Goodbye (feat. Pusha T & Stormzy) 10. Halfway Right

It's not a matter of switching guitars, we don't know if they even have that guitar with them (I know Brad mentioned the With You/Runaway guitar, but I don't think we ever got confirmation that it was included in the rig. I'm sure Astat knows more about that than i do.) Either way, the last thing the sets need is more old songs at the expense of new ones. Hell, I think the 8 songs they're playing from HT and Meteora is too much. Cut SIB, use that Crawling piano slot as a rotation spot for that, BTH, BID etc. Bring back some fan favorites from the more recent albums. Where the hell are NMS, WTCFM, WAK, FM, IMR etc?

NCSM is definitely my #3 on the album, just behind Halfway Right and One More Light

Well the problem with songs like With You or Runaway is they need a specific guitar to play those. It's not like From The Inside, Lying From You, or A Place For My Head, where they have the guitars needed to play those in the rig already. I do agree some rotations in the set would be a welcome change. As for the OML songs, those are some of the best songs in the set right now. TTM, GG, Invisible, OML, all are fantastic additions

No. Headlining set from South America so far

Round 6 is over! Nobody Can Save Me - 3 Talking To Myself - 4 Invisible - 10 Sorry For Now - 6 One More Light - 1 (HOW) Despite my efforts to save it, Invisible is gone 1. Nobody Can Save Me 3. Talking To Myself 5. Invisible 7. Sorry For Now 9. One More Light Sorry For Now Elimination Tracker 1-4. TBD 5. Invisible 6. Sharp Edges 7. Battle Symphony 8. Heavy (feat. Kiiara) 9. Good Goodbye (feat. Pusha T & Stormzy) 10. Halfway Right

1. Talking To Myself (Long Intro) 2. Lost In The Echo 3. Faint (Ext. Outro) 4. No More Sorrow (Long Intro) 5. Empty Spaces 6. When They Come For Me 7. Good Goodbye (Ext. Intro; Live Version) 8. Castle Of Glass (Experience Version; Bridge w/ 'Kenji' v1 + 'Wisdom, Justice, And Love' Speech Samples; 2017 Ending w/ 'A Place For My Head' v1) 9. Sorry For Now 10. Numb ('Numb/Encore' intro/Outro) 11. Invisible 12. Waiting For The End ('Remember The Name' Intro; Wall of Noise Outro) 13. One More Light 14. Burn It Down (Stripped Down Version) 15. Leave Out All The Rest (2017 Version) 16. Final Masquerade 17. Heavy 18. In The End 19. A Line in The Sand (Keyboard Intro) ------------------- 20. What I've Done (2017 Intro; Ext. Guitar Solo Bridge) 21. Nobody Can Save Me 22. One Step Closer (2017 Intro; Ext. Outro) ------------------- 23. Fallout (w/ 'Roads Untraveled' vox) 24. The Catalyst 25. Lying From You / Papercut 26. Bleed It Out (Ext. Intro w/ 'Reading My Eyes' v1; Ext. Bridge w/ 'A Place For My Head' v2 + Bridge, Drum Solo; Ext. Ending w/ Guitar Solo)

You mean One More Light