In response to Josh's comments about the individual members of LP:
Chester: Has developed and changed as a singer over the years. A good comparison is of his screaming on Lying From You - compare 2003 to 2007/08, and I see that Chester has lost his 'golden touch' in terms of his vocal ability. He's quite temperamental live - his voice is so haunting on TLYGYA, yet he always manages to butcher LOATR.
Mike: He's too multi skilled that he doesn't really excel at anything, but I thinks he genuinely tried to improve and develop during the MTM writing process. Hoping for more genius moments from Mike.
Phoenix: May as well not be in the band at the moment. He needs to get everyone to starting calling him Dave again, turn up his bass, and actually do something on stage during the live shows!
Brad: Yeah, he's not that great with guitar. At least on MTM he's shown he can do more than just power chords, and he can actually pull off the In Pieces solo live, so that's promising. As long as he sticks to stuff he can play, he's fine.
Rob: Can't say that Rob's terrible, in fact he seems to be pretty solid most of the time. It's probably more LP's style that contributes to what he actually plays. Or maybe that he simply over practices songs and it loses that creative aspect (eg TLTGYA - referring to the MTM making of DVD).
Joe: Has enough turntablism skill for anything that LP would require, but that's it. I imagine that during the early Xero/Hybrid Theory days Joe would have had a real passion for scratching and developing his skill (and With You shows the result of that). As the nu-metal phase past, and LP moved to write MTM, Joe kinda got left to push buttons (although I would be extremely interested to know what scratching was on the MTM tracks prior to the mixing stage). Since I can't see there being a large amount of scratching on the next album, I'd go as far as suggesting that Joe could try playing another instrument (possibly guitar, which would get him off his riser and allow him to go to the front of the stage for a change. Or maybe that is a bit extreme.