I love you guys for bringing up High Voltage. That'd be unbelievable, the venue would probably explode from concentrated awesomeness. Unfortunately I don't see that happen. I do think however, With You will return, maybe Reading My Eyes and a new song.
In my opinion they could drop Crawling and In The End, but, as mentioned before, that will probably never happen as they also have to meet the needs of the occasional listeners.
Papercut is an absolute must.