Well Mark as I've said before I actually really enjoyed Living Things, but I can see how you and others may not enjoy it I guess.... That being said, I agree with pretty much everything you said about THP. It definitely is better song writing . I personally prefer a little bit cleaner of a sound on studio albums (the "dirty" or "grainy" effects they used on a few of these songs are bugging me, but I'll get over it I'm sure) so I can't say this album is one of my "favorites" yet. But it definitely jams hard. I need to listen to it in my car with my sub now..
Personally, I think Rebellion and Wastelands are my favs from the album. Followed by KTTK and GATS. More listens required to appreciate the other songs completely.