No, I don't download all the shows. I get certain songs from them or whatever, but not each and every one. Hearing the same song from 100 different cities doesn't really float my boat, unless it's different, unique, blah blah blah.
That being said, my favourite one has to be Montreal 08 for all the reasons listed above. And no, not just because I was there. London, Ontario 08 was also pretty good, I thought. But there is an ass load of bias on that one.
Both Toronto shows of the last few years kicked ass. Mark's reaction after he heard HHH (I think it was HHH?) over the phone from Edgefest was hilarious. That was a special show probably never to be repeated. Good times.